All-Time All-ODAC Award Winners
Women
| Year | Player | ODAC Team | |
| 2013 | Lauren Frizzell | First Team | |
| Taylor Guardalabene | First Team | ||
| Tyler Ann Herron | First Team | ||
| Payton Shirey | First Team | ||
| Nicole Powell | Third Team | ||
| 2014 | Allison Fowler | First Team | ODAC Swimmer of the Year |
| Taylor Guardalabene | First Team | ||
| Liz Kleveno | First Team | ||
| Michaela Nolte | First Team | ODAC Rookie of the Year | |
| Jessica Richardson | First Team | ||
| Payton Shirey | First Team | ||
| Jordan Greenburg | Third Team | ||
| Nicole Powell | Third Team | ||
| 2015 | Allison Fowler | First Team | |
| Taylor Guardalabene | First Team | ||
| Michaela Nolte | First Team | ||
| Jessica Richardson | First Team | Bonnie Kestner Sportsmanship Award | |
| Kelsey Jones | Second Team | ||
| Mackenzie Lingle | Second Team | ||
| Holly Roth | Second Team | ||
| Payton Shirey | Second Team | ||
| Marina Moore | Third Team | ||
| Nicole Powell | Third Team | ||
| Dave Griffore | ODAC Coach of the Year | ||
| 2016 | Michaela Nolte | First Team | ODAC Women's Swimmer of the Year |
| Jessica Richardson | First Team | ||
| Taylor Guardalabene | Second Team | ||
| Claire Goodrum | Second Team | ||
| Bri Chessock | Third Team | ||
| Jordan Greenburg | Third Team | ||
| Mackenzie Lingle | Third Team | ||
| Marina Moore | Third Team | ||
| Nicole Powell | Third Team | ||
| Holly Roth | Third Team | ||
| 2017 | Michaela Nolte | First Team | ODAC Scholar-Athlete of the Year |
| Jessica Richardson | First Team | ||
| Bri Chessock | Second Team | ||
| Olivia Anson | Third Team | ||
| Jordan Greenburg | Third Team | ||
| Kelsey Jones | Third Team | ||
| 2018 | Olivia Anson | Second Team | |
| Bri Chessock | Second Team | ||
| Holly Roth | Second Team | ||
| 2019 | Olivia Anson | Second Team | |
| Cat Sweigart | Third Team | ||
| 2020 | Olivia Anson | Third Team |
Men
| Year | Player | ODAC Team | |
| 2018 | Wilson Naff | Second Team | |
| 2020 | Luc Grillet | Second Team |