All-Time All-America Selections
| Year | Name | Position | ||||
| 1934 | Paul Bus Mackey | Guard | ||||
| Alderson Propps | End | |||||
| 1936 | Mark Kegley | Back | ||||
| 1949 | Robert Miller | Back | ||||
| 1950 | Robert Miller | Back | First Team | |||
| James Buddy Earp | Center | |||||
| 1951 | Robert Miller | Back | First Team | |||
| Charles "Chick" Davis | Back | |||||
| James Neblett | Tackle | |||||
| Carl "Bob" Howard | End | |||||
| 1952 | Erwin "Bunny" Saltz | Back | ||||
| 1956 | William Earp | Center | First Team | |||
| Hobart Cawood | Guard | First Team | ||||
| 1957 | Joey Rusek | Guard | ||||
| Harold Lambert | End | |||||
| 1958 | Manuel "Greek" Stoupis | Tackle | First team | |||
| 1959 | Harry H. Yost | Back | ||||
| Levi Otey | End | |||||
| 1960 | Levi Otey | End | ||||
| 1961 | C.A. Burton | Back | ||||
| Hal McHorris | Center | |||||
| Levi Otey | End | |||||
| 1962 | Jack Thomas | Tackle | ||||
| Bill Bryant | Guard | |||||
| Earl Hawkins | Halfback | |||||
| 1963 | Earl Hawkins | Halfback | First Team | |||
| 1967 | Jesse "Sonny" Wade | Quarterback | ||||
| 1968 | Jesse "Sonny" Wade | Quarterback | First Team | |||
| Larry Bales | Offensive Back | |||||
| Fred Selfe | Offensive Center | |||||
| 1969 | Wayne Neese | Offensive Back | ||||
| 1970 | Wayne Neese | Offensive Back | ||||
| David Lee | Tackle | |||||
| 1971 | Bobby Hill | Defensive Back | ||||
| 1973 | Bob Whetsel | Linebacker | ||||
| 1982 | Steve Larus | Tight End | ||||
| 1984 | Steve Larus | Tight End | ||||
| Mike Lindsay | Defensive Back | |||||
| 1985 | Keith Furr | Defensive Back | First Team | |||
| 1986 | Keith Furr | Defensive Back | ||||
| Steve Dean | Offensive Guard | |||||
| Sandy Rogers | Running Back | First Team | ||||
| 1987 | Gary Collier | Quarterback | First Team | |||
| 1988 | Steve Bowman | Defensive Tackle | First Team | |||
| Doug Reavis | Offensive Tackle | |||||
| 1989 | Doug Reavis | Offensive Tackle | First Team | |||
| Billy "B.I." Salyers | Offensive Tackle | |||||
| 1990 | Billy "B.I." Salyers | Offensive Tackle | First Team | |||
| 1991 | Jason Grooms | Defensive Tackle | First Team | |||
| 1992 | Patrick Buchanan | Offensive Tackle | First Team | |||
| Scott Pruner | Defensive End | First Team | ||||
| 1993 | Adam Dowe | Defensive End | ||||
| Ricky Webb | Defensive Back | |||||
| 1994 | Mark Middleton | Punter | ||||
| Darren Reed | Linebacker | |||||
| 1995 | Jamie Harless | Defensive Tackle | ||||
| 1996 | Thomas Nelson | Defensive Back | ||||
| Kevin Rogers | Offensive line | |||||
| 1997 | Jamie Harless | Defensive Tackle | First Team | |||
| Mike Kassnove | Defensive End | |||||
| 1998 | Mike Kassnove | Defensive End | First Team | |||
| John Carmody | Linebacker | |||||
| Micheal Hughes | Offensive line | |||||
| Oliver Jordan | Running Back | |||||
| Isaac Williams | Defensive Tackle | |||||
| 1999 | Charles Peterson | Defensive Back | First Team | |||
| Charles Peterson | Return Specialist | |||||
| 2001 | Jelani Patterson | Defensive End | First Team | |||
| 2006 | Marshall Doss | Linebacker | ||||
| 2008 | Caleb Jennings | Return Specialist | ||||
| 2009 | Caleb Jennings | Running Back | First Team | |||
| 2011 | Devan Sproles | Linebacker | ||||
| 2020* | Jay Swegheimer | Defensive Line | Second Team | |||
| 2024 | Cam Abshire | Wide Receiver | Second Team | |||
| Shawn Collins | Defensive Back | |||||
| 2025 | Ean Rhea | Defensive Line | First Team | |||
| Shawn Collins | Defensive Back | Second Team | ||||
| Italicized players are Honorable Mention All-Americans | ||||||
-